Realistic Fake Cum Recipe: Semen "Shots" Taste-Test & Party Mixology
Mixing realistic-tasting fake cum shots — olfactory notes of cake batter and bleach and all — somehow turned into my most-viewed and most-liked Instagram story yet.

The slide showed me swirling a blender bottle with 8 ounces of this coconut water-based concoction cumcoction.
My followers were both delighted and disgusted when I shared the ingredients list — and my taste-tester play partner probably felt the same way sampling the mix.
He was the first to grimace when taking a shot, and he wasn't the last.
"I think this is our ‘eureka,’" he said, surprised by how human it tasted. You can thank the banana extract and monosodium glutamate for that.
(I know how people feel about essays on cooking blogs, so click here to skip to the realistic-tasting fake cum recipe.)
It only took us a month to finally get around to making fake ejaculate — we were too busy making and tasting actual cum — after my text about how coconut water sometimes tastes like semen, depending on the brand. He actually agreed with me, which I saw and I raised, "It needs L‑arginine for the bitter bleach-like notes, though," in a "Hahahaha, JK.….…… UNLESS?" kind of way.

The scale-tipping motivator we needed was a wet-themed kinky play party.
Mixing a batch for ourselves didn't cut it anymore — we handed out 2‑ounce cups with lids like little gelatin shots, but with ludicrous amounts of artificial ejaculate.
Needless to say, partygoers were skeptical at first. Carrying around a jar to sip and spit, and then snowball back and forth in my play partner's mouth, while others watched, was key to earning trust before they'd accept the mystery mix.
[Upon tasting it, s]omeone else raised her eyebrows in delight. “HMM! I wish more cum tasted like that!”
Cum Lubricant vs. Fake Cum For Drinking
See, cum lube that felt and looked and slipped and stretched realistically for use with sex toys (or just for sex) was familiar to many attendees.
I love when people ask for a realistic-looking cum lube, because it's such an easy answer: shop the hybrid lube section. Even though white water-silicone hybrid personal lubricants aren't always marketed as cum simulation products for fetish purposes, they can pretty much all be used that way (though some are certainly more opaque than others).
These body-safe cum substitutes are great for internal use — water-based for compatibility with a wide range of materials (think toys, condoms, and beyond), with just a little silicone for long-lasting gel-like glide, and an emulsifier to keep the formula stable.

Finding cum simulation lube for roleplay is pretty straightforward.
But fetish-level fake cum mixology for drinking was a different story.
[C]oconut water tastes like cum, and I couldn't dispute that that was somewhat true… A body-safe cum concoction might be a bit harder to execute, but I think it’s possible, as coconut-flavored lube exists.
So here's what we combined, how we (and others) felt about different iterations (believe me: it was a mixed bag), and what I'd do differently for the next batch.

Realistic-Tasting Fake Cum Recipe
Here’s my edible semen substitute recipe — based on food science manuals and fetish forums related to breeding and cum play:
- 1 cup coconut water
- 1/4 tsp xanthan gum
- 1/4 tsp L‑arginine
- A little pinch of monosodium glutamate
- Potassium chloride or table salt to taste
- 1 drop banana extract
I ended up making two batches of realistic-tasting fake cum for oral:
- One with the original recipe above.
- One with some almond extract, less salt, and MSG (just a few crystals), and some guar gum.
Note: Due to the sugar content in the coconut water, this recipe is not intended for use as a lubricant.
A body-safe cum concoction might be a bit harder to execute, but I think it’s possible, as coconut-flavored lube exists. Thanks, Hathor/SUTIL, for one of the best-tasting lubes I have ever tried, OMG. I didn’t imagine shouting them out in an instructional cum fetish post until now.
So, Why These Ingredients?
Someone at a previous party pointed out that coconut water tastes like cum, and I couldn't dispute that that was somewhat true of some brands, some times of year. Kirkland coconut water during the summer in the USA? Definitely. Coconut water fresh from a coconut? Hmm, maybe sometimes.
However, it needed L‑arginine or something else bitter for the bleach-like notes. The salts added, well, the saltiness and the savory. And banana extract was the thing that made it uncannily human.
FURTHER READING: Weirdly Specific Penis Facts You (Probably) Didn't Know: coagulating cum, Herbalife, 4‑hour erections, and more

And why xanthan gum for texture? It’s a well-documented thickening agent for food and body care products. One taster’s familiarity with it was because she has diabetes and would use xanthan gum to adjust baking recipes for texture and consistency when swapping sugar out for another sweetener.
You can also use guar gum, but I wish I hadn’t. It behaves quite differently from xanthan gum. Almond extract was another mistake that ruined that batch.
(But it’s okay — I saved the sweetest to sip and share with my play partner.)
Things I Would Do Differently Next Time
- Use more xanthan gum and less MSG from the start.
- My play partner’s cum tends to be thicker.
- He kept insisting that his tasted way better than the mix, which I’m inclined to agree with. Also, his cum is more bitter and not nearly as salty.
- Mix wet and dry ingredients separately to reduce clumping. (More on that coming right up.)
- Set aside extra time and tools for the guar gum — or skip it entirely.
- Xanthan gum thickens the mix, but guar gum is what makes it stick, resulting in stringy strands. Why would I not want my edible semen shots to do that? It turns out that guar gum is notoriously difficult to work with and tends to clump.
- I didn’t have a blender — and the shaker bottle whisk wasn’t cutting it — so I tried a frother, thinking I could just submerge it entirely and keep it steady, to stir the liquid with minimal air. It was hard to beat the clock (get this mix ready in time for the party), stir out the clumps, let the air bubbles settle, and dilute out the excess almond extract. (Up next.)
- Use less (if any) almond extract.
- The intention was to round out and balance the other tastes — the bitter, the umami, all of it. I didn’t have a dropper with me by the time I started the second batch, and I done goofed adding enough to take it from hyper-realistic fake cum to marzipan cumfection.
- So I tried mixing more to dilute the almond taste. It still tasted plausibly like cum by the time I got ready for the party, but then again, it also probably didn’t evenly mix.
- In retrospect, I should have dipped a toothpick in the almond extract and then into the edible faux semen shaker. That’s all it takes.
- Maybe add the slightest bit of cocoa powder for more pronounced bitterness.

Of course, I’d try that last one during time set aside for experimentation — not during a time crunch between fucking and minimal sleep and maximal partying (and fucking at a party where we were, again, the last ones at the venue after all the other guests had gone home).
He kept insisting that his tasted way better than the mix, which I’m inclined to agree with.
Reactions to Sharing Simulated Semen at a Party
I greeted my friend by holding out a shot cup.
“Do I have to drink all of this?”
“You don’t have to drink any of it, homie. I’m just offering!”
She watched her partner try some first. Their reaction was one of furrowing their brows, squinting, and grimacing with small but vigorous nods. I couldn’t tell whether it was a positive reaction until they said, “Oh, yeah. That’s cum.”

Someone else raised her eyebrows in delight. “HMM! I wish more cum tasted like that!”
Among those who hadn’t tasted semen before, their responses were variants of “THAT’S what cum tastes like?!” and “I’m so glad I’m allergic to it.”
My overall favorite reactions were:
- Something along the lines of, “I’ve been to kink parties for a long time, and this is the first I’ve seen anything like this.”
- Looking at my cumfection jar and commenting, “Could you imagine how long it would take to save up all that cum?”
- The international guy who flew in from a relatively conservative country. It was his first-ever play party, and he took that shot like a champ.
Finally, by the next day, when I had some samples left to share, we were getting to the sweeter aliquots, which were understandably critiqued accordingly, and because they were too bubbly.
Which is fine — done is better than perfect, though someone then commented that overly sweet semen was how he realized he was pre-diabetic.

Closing Thoughts on Cumfectionary Concoctions
I’d say the base formula was a banger, though I’d adjust it to be more bitter and less salty to match my play partner’s taste. Of course, cum varies in taste and consistency from person to person and session to session. Diet, hydration, and overall health all affect the experience of one’s semen.
I’m open to making another real-feeling and tasting cum fetish mix that’s more body-safe for vaginal use, and I think that’s possible when combining coconut-flavored lube with a water-silicone hybrid.
It would be cool to refine edible simulated semen to the point of sticky strands with guar gum, but it’s more work than I initially bargained for.
At that point, I think my play partner and I would rather snowball his actual cum.
Our first date included spitting coconut water into each other’s mouths in the parking lot of a museum, but it definitely wouldn’t be the last time we did that.
FURTHER READING:
This post contains a sponsored link!
As usual, these feral field notes were written by me.
If you want to advertise on my blog, check out my collaboration policies and code of conduct.
Discover more from Super Smash Cache
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.